The 7 Worst Rookie Prepper Mistakes

By some estimates,* 3 million Americans consider themselves “preppers,” and Joel Skousen estimates that for every one prepping, ten are thinking about it. If you’re one of those ten, you need to avoid these common mistakes I’ve seen new preppers make (and admittedly some of which I’ve made myself).

(*The estimates I have are based on what I consider to be reliable information. Trade groups have conducted research to determine the market influence of the self-described “active prepper” demographic. I have not seen these proprietary reports, but I have spoken with individuals who wish to remain anonymous and who claim to have first-hand knowledge of them.)

1. Obsessing About Doomsday

If a nuclear strike is your primary concern where you live, move. With that exception, the first step in preparing for emergencies is not to quit your job, sell the house, and move to Utah. The first thing you need to do is prepare for likely emergencies. It does you no good to sell the house and move into an off-grid, radiation-shielded bunker if you don’t even know how much food to store in it, how to filter your water, or how to escape your rat hole if it’s ever compromised. I’m not saying you’ll never need a fallout shelter; I’m saying power outages happen every year and sometimes last several days or weeks, and nuclear attacks are a little more rare.

Assess the risks in your area and be ready for them. The most common risk is interruption of public utilities by any number of natural causes, so prepare to eat, drink, shelter yourself, and administer first aid for at least two weeks before you start digging that fallout shelter.

2. Relying on Gadgets Instead of Skills

Tools are useful, but only if you know how to use them. I do product reviews, so I have a lot of gear lying around, most of which adds some measure of convenience, but very little of it is truly essential. Skills, on the other hand, are definitely essential. For example, I have several types of compact camp stoves that use available fuels like twigs and pine cones to boil a quart or so of water in just a few minutes. Are they handy? You bet. But before you buy any of them, know how to do without them, and spend that money getting your food and water stock up to par.

As another example, I have water bottles with an integrated filter so I can dip water out of a roadside ditch and safely drink it. But before I ever owned one of those, I knew how to make a filter with moss, grass, a shirt sleeve, and homemade charcoal.

3. Obsessing About “Bugging Out”

If you live in the urban jungle and a hurricane or Nor’Easter is bearing down, you might be wise to leave well ahead of time. But what if you can’t? What if your family is scattered around town, and by the time they all get home the escape routes are hopelessly snarled? You can’t risk running out of gas on the highway, so you decide you’re better off remaining at the house. If that’s the case, it had better be ready for you to “bug in.”

4. Not Having an Evacuation Plan

This is the flip side of the previous point — you might live in a relatively secure rural location and your primary strategy is to hunker down in the event of some sort of disaster. You’re ready to bug in until the second coming. That’s great, but what if you have to leave? What if you’re overrun with mobs from the city? What if your place burns? What if it’s confiscated? Your primary location might be compromised any number of ways, so you need a contingency plan for that. It might be a hunting cabin in the next state, or the “old home place” your grandparents passed down, or maybe an arrangement with a friend or family member where you mutually serve each other as a secondary safe retreat. Whatever the case, you need someplace to go and some way to get there, all of which are worked out in advance. Don’t try to set this up while the hurricane is bearing down.

5. Putting All Your Eggs in One Basket

The previous point illustrates a principle that should apply in all aspects of preparation — contingency planning. You need plan A and plan B. Don’t store all your food in one room — it might burn, get flooded, or get stolen. Same with your guns, water, money, clothes, tools…. Don’t plan just one evacuation route. Don’t have just one flashlight. Make sure your car has a spare tire, a small gas can, and a siphon hose.

Now apply this principle to everything you do by way of emergency preparation.

6. Not Having a Support and Communications Network

This comes from yet another obsession; this one about OPSEC, or Operational Security, which is being extremely secretive about your emergency planning. By all means, be wise about sharing your plans, but no man is an island — you need a support and communications network. Our grandparents called this network “community,” and the people who constituted it were known as “neighbors,” but people hardly know their neighbors anymore. Everybody’s watching TV or playing Black Ops (I can’t tell you how much goofy advice I get from people who’ve only ever handled a First Person Shooter gun). Dependency on the state destroys community (and society in general); we need to rebuild community again.

But back to the point: Yes, you need to be smart about how much and whom you tell, but when unreliable government services go down (they’re always the first thing to go), your neighbors will suddenly be very valuable again — unless they didn’t prepare, in which case they could suddenly become your most immediate threat.

The network is not completely incompatible with operational security. Everybody knows I prep, and a good many people know some of my stock locations, but almost no one knows even half of them, or what is there. So go ahead, develop mutually beneficial relationships and help everyone get ready. When your neighbor preps, it doesn’t just help him; it helps you too. And vice versa.

7. Failing to Practice

Would you build a car and sell it without test-driving it? No. Would you serve a soup without tasting it? Of course not. So don’t put your family at the mercy of an emergency plan that has never seen a drill. The day your house burns is not the day to learn how to escape a burning house; the day you have to evacuate is not the day to chart your route; and the day the blizzard strikes is not the day to stock up on food and water.

And Here Are a Few More Typical Prepper Mistakes

  1. Failing to Make Preparation a Part of Everyday Routine. It’s easy to integrate basic readiness into your everyday routine. Buy meat by the case and trim it yourself, and use the trimmings somehow. Ditch the lighter fluid and figure out some other way to light that charcoal grill. In fact, make your own charcoal. Check the first aid kit in your car. Change the spare tire, just for practice. Learn a new knot. Plant a garden and tend it… then harvest it! Those skills and the mindset undergirding them have been lost, but you can regain them and teach them to the next generation.
  2. Leaving Your EDC Behind. It’s called an “everyday carry” kit because you’re supposed to carry it everyday. If it’s too bulky and inconvenient, trim it back or alter your carry method. Consider my recommended “pocket EDC” method.
  3. Obsession With Prepping. Let’s be clear; a healthy, happy family is more important than extending your food stock another month. Everything in the family begins with the husband-wife relationship. Make sure that’s solid above all else, and everything else will fall into place.


Our grandparents didn’t have a name for “prepping;” they just called it “living.” My grandparents never ate a chicken they hadn’t raised themselves. They had a garden and “put up” food every year. They mended clothes. They made scarves out of worn out sweaters.

It’s not practical to completely alter your way of life and return to the way your grandparents lived (back then, 90% of the population was rural; now 90% is urban or suburban). But you don’t have to do that in order to be ready for emergencies. The only thing that has to change fundamentally is this: You need to regain a certain degree of self-reliance and reliance on reliable resources. Your family can’t count on FEMA; they have to count on you. Don’t disappoint them.


27 thoughts on “The 7 Worst Rookie Prepper Mistakes”

  1. ALL very good ‘INTEL’. This “IS” practical and ‘effective’ information… ONLY if YOU are willing to put it into operation. It’s not ‘panic’, it’s a way of life.

    Why did our Grandparents have these great skills? Because they were CLOSER to our ‘roots’, to the real reasons America ‘IS’ what it ‘IS’. Do NOT let these skills simply vanish.

    Pride and humility and frugality can all live happily together. YOU are the key.

        1. It’s WEIRD when people capitalize random WORDS in their SENTENCE as if to emphasize what THEY are saying. It seems YOU just pick words willy-NILLY and capitalize THEM.

          1. Serious criticism. I’m sorry that grammatical emphasis offends your better sensibilities. Perhaps it would be best if you simply ignored any of my commentary. Enjoy the celebration of our Saviors sacrifice for us. Cheers!

          2. Then why bug him about it??
            Instead of saying “I agree with you, but”… just started being picky about his typing. He’s not looking for an English “grade” for his writing ability……just expressing his viewpoint.

          3. Read his paragraph out loud, applying emphasis to every word that is capitalized. You will see why I said it is random.
            It’s also a very poor way of writing in english.

            I think, contrary to what you posited, it helps weak minded people write better. Or at the very least, makes people think they are better conveying an assertion, when in reality they are making their paragraph annoying to read.
            Also, when writing in english, we don’t use quotation marks for emphasis.

          4. Maybe it helps weak minded people read better?? Nobody can hear our inflections when we READ, so using caps now and then helps emphasize certain words. You said he did this on “random” words, when you KNOW that isn’t true on his part…..WHY???

          5. you can’t hear inflections but you get the message this is important and if skimming the material you might stop and look at and around the caps.

          6. Annoying is only to the eye of the reader (as beauty is in the eye of the beholder). But ESPECIALLY when the statement goes against the reader’s point of view.
            He made a statement you didn’t like, so you focused on an off-topic point to divert the subject. His point stands…..whether you like HOW he said it or not.

          7. If that works for you, fine…..but too many Libtards out there can’t read anyway, so CAPS helps them see better…. 😉

          8. Good reply and most of us can figure out why you (and many others) use caps to EMPHASIZE certain words since no-one can hear our voices as we type.

  2. SNO, You are the man. Love the vids, blogs, tips, knowledge. Please keep em coming! Stuck in Cali and would love some more tips for use in earthquake country. Recommendations etc..

  3. Also lets add to start with practical fundamental preps and work yourself in a circle out of those once established. I see too many newbies buy cool stuff like Geiger counters, Israeli gas masks (circa 1972) and body armor before covering basics like more than a couple of days of food, drinking water, and basic medical supplies.

    And I see these guys plunging into this with no plan of action or sense of practical application. Great, so you have 800# of pinto beans under your bed… but you don’t even like pinto beans, let alone have any idea how to prepare them and no spices to make them edible.

    1. This is so true. I’ve seen this plenty of times and it always makes me shake my head. They have the right thoughts, and their heart is in the right place, but they don’t have any guidelines or someone to help them along. I’ve helped several people out because they wanted to “get ready” but didn’t know how. Every person is different, and their needs are different. Sadly, there are going to be people we can’t help when the SHTF. Diabetics, or people requiring medication to live. They may have a month’s supply, but if something happens just before they get their prescription refilled, it’s going to be a bit of a problem for them.

  4. You always have such great advice. My kids and I really enjoy watching the videos and then my husband and I often discuss your articles. I really appreciate the first and last bits you have about not obsessing. It is way too easy to get caught up in the fear of “what if.” Living our lives for the here and now and knowing that tomorrow I may not be able to go to the store and preparing for that eventuality is simply wisdom. Thanks for the reminder!

    1. right. a screw driver to the bottom of the tank and a dishpan will get you every ounce of gas in every tank your poke. leave the siphon house behind carry a collapsible bucket instead and a solid knife.
      Do any of you have any idea how far into the gas tank you have to go before you start sucking gas?

    1. Most of our Grandparents and Great Grandparents lived through the Great Depression and HAD to “make do” with what they had. (I’ve even heard of ladies getting used flour sacks and making clothing out of them back then!) The thing we have to remember this time around is the next Depression will be MUCH WORSE than the last one. Why, you may ask??
      1. Hardly anyone was on the public-dole back then……they were either too proud to “stoop that low” or just went ahead and “fended for themselves”. Now as many as 40% of our population are getting food stamps and welfare….and actually EXPECT (entitlement mentality) getting it!!
      THINK what will happen with all those non-working mouths to feed when they can’t get any food!!!
      2. Back then the dollar was worth something…….this time (because of QE-3 and Counterfeit printing of money) the dollar will be worth HALF AND/OR LESS…..maybe even ZERO (Google Zimbabwe)!!! Can you even IMAGINE what that means to people who have a little money tucked away “for that rainy day” and need to depend on it for their needs…..let alone those who have NOTHING???
      3. The combination of both of these at the SAME TIME is UNIMAGINABLE!!!! As we all learned in Boy and Girl Scouts many years ago…….”BE PREPARED”…’s all up to YOU!!!

  5. For the past 3 years we have been raising our own meat, and growing ask of our veggies and fruits, and canning… Every year I learn a better method for everything we do… I wish everyone could be as lucky as us… Only way to get better at anything is PRACTICE, PRACTICE, PRACTICE!

  6. Excellent post. Some I have noticed include:
    Not paying attention to hygienic needs. Cleanliness will be a health issue.

    Not dealing with medical concerns now while the system is up.
    Smoking, high stress and nicotine withdrawl is an ugly combination.
    Not having a strategy for home hardening for a bug in.

  7. Here are a few other “mistakes” I’ve seen preppers make.
    1. Thinking you have to have everything right away. It’s cool to have all the stuff you need for your bug out location, and all the supplies you’ll need for bugging in. The sad truth is that we’re not rich (at least I’m not). We need to build up our supplies over time. We need to find yard sales, we need to find sales at the various stores. We need to build the collection up over time. The sooner you start, the quicker you’ll cross that finish line.
    2. Plan for foul weather. Every climate region is different. I live in the Puget Sound area, and we’re known for one thing…rain. Lots of rain. We’re not known for snow. We’re not known for hurricane force winds. Plan your bug out tests for bad weather. Test yourselves when it’s at it’s worst, not when it’s at it’s best. The best training I’ve done was a bug out drill at night. As in, it started after sunset. It’s amazing how many things are different when there’s no light (or limited light).
    3. Practice returning to home from your work location, or where you commonly shop. The idea here is simple. Say you have a major earthquake. We’re talking a 9.5 on the Richter Scale or higher. The roads are not drivable. The bridges are all collapsed. Look at the power lines and imagine that they are down. How do you get back home? If you work 13 miles from your house, you’ll have to get back to your house and hope it’s still standing. Are you prepared to help others along the way? Are you willing to divert your course if it means helping someone else? Do you have a physical copy of a map to get you back home?

    SnoMan, I like your blog from what I’ve seen of it. I’ll be stopping by frequently. Stay frosty.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top